this topic comes up on a regular basis. the best question should be what will it cost me to fix it? now tell me does this first picture look to you like $1500? the two bumpers, 4 guards and 4 angled carriage bolts cost me that to straighten and re plate not to mention the 50 bucks getting the one missing guard. so far I have about $5000 in plating on this 1500 dollar car. it's all laying in the back of it. a caddy of the same year would be about twice that. but at least you could get replacement parts for the caddy that rear bumper off the Pontiac is a hard one to find.